By Amiya Jha,
If potential rapists knew that they would be found out there would be far fewer rapes. The trouble is that they don’t know this and believe they will get away – often even with murder.
They also don’t know that post-Nirbhaya the penalty for rape is almost as stiff as for any other heinous crime. This was unthinkable before the 16 December 2012 gangrape, whose victim, a paramedic, came to be addressed as Nirbhaya (the fearless one) and caused major changes to be made in rape laws. (Under Indian law rape victims cannot be named).
So if this component – telling these nascent predators on the prowl that the crime is bound to be detected – could be made part of public protests and awareness programmes, the menace could be more effectively tackled. For until now these have been largely limited to denouncing the incidents and mobilising public outrage against them. But to have a lasting impact they need to go further and find ways of sending out the message to the likely perpetrators themselves so they are forewarned about what’s coming and in store for them.
Most come from the ill-informed underclass, such as Delhi’s underbelly, that rarely follows the news. Thus documentaries showing how the crimes that they imagined would go untraced were nailed and the culprits brought to book should be screened in neighbourhoods, and not just on TV, to ensure maximum community participation and immediacy. These should be accompanied by door-to-door campaigning and counselling involving all members of potentially vulnerable sections.
Throughout the effort should be not only to condemn the outrages, but also more and more to showcase actual incidents to hammer home the point that such crimes do not go unpunished. This is what is missing. For instance the juvenile rapists of a toddler who was kidnapped from a Ramlila venue during a blackout thought they would never be traced, but the police tracked them within hours. In this case they were helped because as in past such cases the victim was known to the victimiser. In others mobile records have served to provide clinching clues and evidence.
Besides, crime surveillance technology has vastly improved over the years as have changes in rape laws. Till some 20 years ago rapists were frequently let off for want of concrete on-the-spot evidence. It was only after circumstantial evidence (often the only one in rape cases) came to be given primacy that the conviction rate improved.
And yet the rape graph keeps rising, and it should be asked why. Where the police are found lacking is that they almost never act till the atrocity is reported. As in other spheres, there is no prevention effort here either.
The problem is compounded by the lack of dedicated police staff trained in crime prevention. Accordingly, protesters must also highlight these, even as they slam police complicity, such as when they are accused of burying cases in exchange for bribes.
What thus calls to be addressed is this constituency of potential rapists, those that are on the make and yet to make their first strike. Yet unfortunately what dominates the public discourse is the politics over rape day after day till the next major atrocity shows up. The entire effort is geared to tracking crimes, none to prevent their occurrence. Even visits by women police to schools are aimed to get victims to come out with their histories, so the wrongdoers can be identified and the former empowered. No programme puts the emphasis on prevention.
What both the government and law enforcers propose are measures to deter crimes; neither offers a clear comprehensive crime reduction strategy. It’s taken to be a given that rapes will continue. On February 20 for instance Delhi Police Commissioner proposed setting up “self defence training workshops for girls right from the school level”. And most recently on October 21, Bassi suggested including “moral science lessons” in schools to curb the menace. Who will deliver these though? And what’s to be the content and mode of delivery on this sensitive issue before such young audiences?
For its part the Arvind Kejriwal government is all set to have in place a “commission of inquiry on women’s safety”. According to a Times of India report his government is “also exploring a parallel policing system by way of ‘special police stations'”. This, however, will only serve to open up yet another front in the long going war of attrition between the state and Central governments. Where Kejriwal gets the thumbs-up is his proposal to treat minors above the age of 15 to be tried for rape as adults. The boys who raped the toddler were all under 17, and could get away with probation as one of the accused in the Nirbhaya case.
But for the most part the Kejriwal government has achieved little on the ground. In May it said 2,500 marshals were being deployed in buses plying the city. It claimed that personnel of Home Guard and Civil Defence were being trained to deter crimes against women commuters. Transport Minister Gopal Rai also said there were plans to install CCTV cameras in 200 buses in the first phase. In Its pre-poll manifesto the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) pledged to set up a women’s security force made up of a 10,000 strong Home Guard. But its turf war with the Centre that continues apace has put it all in cold storage and future tense, as most of the rest of its proposals. The women’s commission initiative is also not likely to meet a better fate, say those familiar with the matter.
The IANS reports that Delhi records 40 cases of crimes against women every day -leading with incidents of rape, molestation and sexual harassment in public. The Delhi Police claims that it has solved more than 90 percent of these cases. Even if that were true, why does the crime rate go on rising year after year? As one Reuter report said, “Despite the furore in the wake of the 16 December 2012 gang rape there has been a record 35 percent rise with 1,794 rapes being reported this year against 1,330 last year.”
Yet the police claim they are doing all they can to boost crime deterrence, such as installing 24×7 women’s helplines, even as their own statistics put the number of cases reported till December 15 last year at 14,687, up from 12,410 in 2013.
Thus the number of those who believe that they can rape and kill and get away has kept growing, while the public is advised to take lessons in the martial arts.
—
Amiya Jha is a senior journalist based in New Delhi. He can be contacted at [email protected].
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed within this article are the personal opinions of the author. IndiaTomorrow.net is not responsible for the accuracy, completeness, suitability, or validity of any information on this article. All information is provided on an as-is basis. The information, facts or opinions appearing in the article may not reflect the views of IndiaTomorrow.net and IndiaTomorrow.net does not assume any responsibility or liability for the same.

