Mr Abhay Kumar’s review-article based on my latest book, “Opinions, Welcome and Unwelcome: Impressions of an Edit Page Editor”, carried by Radiance Viewsweekly (March 31, 2026) and India Tomorrow news portal, has some serious and damaging factual inaccuracies. That is why I felt compelled to come out with this rejoinder.
Here I am reminded of the foundational principle of ethical journalism, propounded in 1921 by the Editor of The Manchester Guardian (now The Guardian), CP Scott: “Comment is free, but facts are sacred.” A critic has every right to offer any kind of opinion (meaningful or meaningless), but what he says must be based on facts. He cannot be allowed to create an edifice on the basis of factual inaccuracies.
The first paragraph of Mr Kumar’s review-article says that I have “nearly four decades of experience in the field” (of journalism) though the truth is that I have been in this noble profession for 55 years. It is clearly mentioned in my book that “I actually started cutting my teeth into the profession in December 1970” when I joined Radiance as a proof-reader (Chapter 3, page 27). The Working Journalists (Conditions of Service) and Miscellaneous Provisions Act of 1955 says that proof-readers (though they have almost become extinct today) are also media professionals. Even otherwise, I became a journalist of the conventional kind in 1975 (which means over half a century ago) when I brought out my own monthly newsmagazine and subsequently joined a Delhi-based news agency as a Staff Reporter. The 1975 Emergency proved to be a blessing in disguise for me, as I have mentioned somewhere in my book.
ALSO READ: Book: Opinions, Welcome and Unwelcome: Impressions of an Edit Page Editor
This major lapse could have been corrected, but, unfortunately, those who edited Mr Kumar’s piece of writing did not bother about cross-checking the fact by referring to my book or other available sources. His sweeping commentary indicates that the review has been carried almost unedited. Even my name gets mentioned so many times as “Syed Nooruzzaman” though my family name could have been edited out subsequently. When I brought this to the reviewer’s attention over the phone, he admitted that his calculation was based on the number of years I spent as a journalist at the weekly magazine concerned and at The Tribune of Chandigarh. Going by his understanding of the subject, one ceases to be a journalist once one retires from the institution where one had been employed till the age of superannuation. This is far from reality. I remain part of the profession even after saying ‘alvida’ to The Tribune in June 2013 by contributing to different publications, including Tehelka magazine.
When Mr Kumar talks of my innings at The Tribune, he points out that “Though he (the author) spent the greater part of his professional life at The Tribune, where he served in various capacities — from (being) a Sub-Editor to Assistant Editor — for more than three decades, his early journalistic training was at Radiance Viewsweekly.” This is again not the truth. This shows his utterly casual style of handling a sensitive subject.
My book clearly mentions that I joined The Tribune as a Trainee Sub-Editor in 1979 and retired from the historic daily as a Deputy Editor, a very senior position that came my way after remaining an Assistant Editor for many years.
I had been with The Tribune for full one year as a trainee journalist like many others. The paper had a proper arrangement for training desk journalists and it is clearly mentioned in the book. There was no such facility available at Radiance. Whatever we learnt as part of the weekly’s editorial staff, we did it with our own efforts. Despite being on the staff of Radiance, I would contribute book-reviews and articles to Hindustan Times, Patriot, Link weekly, Thought weekly, etc, and learnt a lot in the process during the seventies. These facts are clearly mentioned in my memoir.
Smelling a rat whenever there is a discussion concerning the minorities and other such sections will take us nowhere. The reviewer refuses to believe that there was a time when an efficient and dependable Muslim could be patronised by an upper caste non-Muslim and would move up the professional ladder without bothering about maintaining “neutrality”, as he alleges. One can find such people today, too, the efforts to spread social poison notwithstanding.
The activist in him is, perhaps, not aware of the fact that there is a system which a journalist has to follow even if he/she occupies a senior position in an organisation. You cannot be allowed to do whatever you wish to, as real freedom is restricted freedom. When we wrote editorials, we took a stand as agreed upon after a thorough discussion in the morning editorial conference. One has to keep in mind the consensus reached at the meeting.
For his kind information, I, a Muslim, was allowed to write on most of the sensitive subjects like Pakistan, terrorism, Jammu and Kashmir and nuclear politics. The different Chief Editors under whom I got opportunities to work had no problem with my handling of even sensitive subjects. There is, therefore, no reason to accuse them of bias, etc. One has to win the confidence of one’s seniors by being competent, responsible, dependable and a man of integrity. A casual type or a compulsive fault-finder cannot survive even in a secular organisation like The Tribune if he does not bother about the system or the prevailing practices.
Now let us have a look at the question the reviewer has raised concerning the deprived communities. Some of us (seniors) in The Tribune had been conscious of the fact that we had very few journalists belonging to the Dalits, the OBCs, the minorities, et al. We tried to ensure that candidates with this kind of a social background got opportunities to become journalists, and we were successful in some cases. But, unfortunately, we rarely got applications from persons coming from these communities. The issue has been discussed in my book, though briefly. It is surprising how Mr Kumar missed it.
–Syed Nooruzzaman

