By Mumtaz Alam, IndiaTomorrow.net,
New Delhi, 07 Dec 2014: “Our analysis relating to the reserved constituencies for the Scheduled Caste candidates in three states of Uttar Pradesh, Bihar and West Bengal suggests that there is truth in the allegation,” Sachar Committee had said in its report in 2006 referring to an old allegation that by reserving Muslim-dominated seats for SC, the religious minority community is being systematically denied political participation.
The panel headed by Justice Rajindar Sachar had then hoped the Delimitation Commission would undo the wrong. But eight years later, the situation has hardly changed, and more interestingly, the Commission doesn’t have answer or doesn’t want to offer one to counter the allegation.
A number of Lok Sabha and Assembly constituencies with substantial Muslim voter population are reserved for SC even though the SC population is not high there. Contrarily, constituencies with comparatively lesser Muslim voter population remain unreserved even though they have sizeable SC population. It was suggested to the Sachar Committee that it would be more equitable to reserve those constituencies where voter population of SCs is high rather than those where it is low and, instead, Muslim presence is high.
Even before and after the Sachar panel, the Muslim community has raised the issue of discrimination but couldn’t find an answer. Even the Delimitation Commission or Boundary Commission, set up by the government at specific interval of time to fix limits or boundaries of legislative constituencies, also doesn’t talk about methodology, if any, for reserving a seat for SC or ST.
The question about the methodology is genuine and commonly asked, and even the Commission admits it.
In the section of FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions) on the website of Delimitation Commission, there are 14 questions. The panel doesn’t answer each question separately. It has three paragraphs as a collective answer to all. The Q. No. 8 reads: How is the reservation of seats for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes decided? The commission doesn’t say a word in response to this question.
In October, a Muslim lawyer and community leader had sent a letter to President and Prime Minister highlighting the issue and demanding Muslim-dominated seats be reserved for Muslims or at least be de-reserve for SC. He had demanded proportionate representation to the Muslim minority in state Assemblies and Lok Sabha.
Adv. Shahid Ali’s letter dated 16th Oct was forwarded to the Delimitation Commission. Ali got a two-para reply to his 5-page letter last month.
In its reply, the Commission refers to constitutional provisions under which legislative seats are reserved for SCs and STs.
“I am directed to refer to your petition dated 16.10.2014 on the subject cited and to state that seats for SCs and STs only in Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies are reserved as per the provisions of Articles 330 and 332 of the Constitution of India. Under the above provisions read with Section 9(1)(c) and 9(1)(d) of the Delimitation Act, 2002, the seats in Legislative Assemblies of all States/ Union Territories including Uttar Pradesh and the seats in the House of the People were accordingly reserved for the SCs/STs…” said Dilip K. Varma, under secretary at the Commission in his 25th Nov reply.
The panel also made it clear that there is no constitutional provision for reserving seats for Muslims.
“There is no provision in the Constitution or in the Delimitation Act, 2002 to reserve seats for Muslims or any religious minority in Lok Sabha/State Legislative Assemblies,” said Varma.
Again there is no answer to the question: Why are Muslim-dominated seats reserved for SCs or STs?

Delimitation Commission on reservation of legislative seats for Muslims
Talking to IndiaTomorrow.net, Adv. Shahid Ali, who is also President of United Muslim Front, said it is a structural bias against the minority.
“Reserving Muslim-dominated seats for Scheduled Caste and leaving Scheduled Caste-dominated seats as general is a big discrimination against Muslims, and this must end,” said Ali.
He also pointed to the 1950 presidential order through which Dalit Muslims and Christians have been barred from SC status for last 60 years.
When Muslims ask for reservation they are said reservation cannot be given on the basis of religion, but interestingly on the very basis of religion Muslims and Christians have been kept out of SC category, he pointed out.
Dr Syed Zafar Mahmood, President, Zakat Foundation of India who has often written on reservation of Muslim-dominated seats for SC says: As per Census of India there are 13.4% Muslims in the country. At this rate, there should be 73 Muslims in Lok Sabha (lower house) which has 543 seats. But, since 1952 till now, the average number of Muslims in Lok Sabha has been less than 27.
He offers figures about Muslim-dominated seats reserved for SC.
In Uttar Pradesh, Nagina Lok Sabha constituency (53% Muslims; 21% SCs) is reserved for SC, but Rae Bareli (6% Muslims; 29% SCs) is not reserved. In Assam, Karimganj Lok Sabha constituency (52% Muslims; 12% SCs) is reserved for SCs, but Dibrugarh and Jorhat (both with 5% Muslims or less) are not reserved. In West Bengal, Khargram assembly constituency (50% Muslims; 23% SCs) is reserved for SCs, but Tufanganj (16% Muslims; 53% SCs) is not reserved. In Bihar, Bagaha assembly constituency (23% Muslims; 14% SCs) is reserved for SCs, but Balia (3% Muslims; 19% SCs) is not reserved. And the list goes on.
The Sachar Committee (formally called Prime Minister’s High Level Committee For Preparation of Report on Social, Economic and Educational Status of the Muslim Community of India) had expressed hope that the matter would receive the attention of the government.
“The Committee hopes that it would receive the attention of the Government immediately because the Delimitation Commission is at present engaged in this exercise and evidently any suggestion or any exercise to be done by it has to be undertaken during the current term of the present Delimitation Commission,” the panel had said in its report in 2006.
Early this year, Dr. Mahmood had written to Prime Minister of India to appoint the next Delimitation Commission at the earliest asking it to remove the above mentioned anomalies and restore constitutional justice to Muslims.
Since Independence, such Delimitation Commissions have been constituted four times – in 1952, 1963, 1973 and 2002.
___
Follow the writer on Twitter @MumtazAlam1978

