Wednesday, November 18, 2026
HomeLatest PostsWhy this silence, Sir? Please say something

Why this silence, Sir? Please say something

By Dr. Saleem Khan

MUMBAI: On the martyrdom of Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Sayyid Ali Ali Khamenei, his friends and even his enemies said something. But our outspoken Prime Minister Narendra Modi remains silent. In 2016, Narendra Modi had said that India’s relationship with Iran is as old as history itself. At that time, Iran not only sold crude oil to India at cheaper rates but also accepted payment in Indian currency. It agreed to jointly develop the Chabahar Port, which was seen as a counter to Pakistan and China’s Gwadar Port.

But times changed. The United States imposed economic sanctions on Iran and prevented India from purchasing Iranian oil. Narendra Modi surrendered. America, considering itself the “Vishwa Guru,” took its obedient student under its wing and locked him in a cage. In 2026, America told India to withdraw from Chabahar Port. Modi complied without hesitation. Yet, on the martyrdom of Ayatollah Khamenei, Modi could not even gather the courage to send a condolence message, fearing displeasure from America and Israel.

The Prime Minister, known for his “56-inch chest” and red eyes that supposedly frighten China, seems aptly described by the poet Parvez Rahmani:

“Is the pen fasting today, or is the paper observing piety?

What is this silence, sir? Please say something.”

India’s old friend, Russian President Vladimir Putin, strongly condemned the attack on Ayatollah Sayyid Ali Khamenei and his family, calling it a “cold-blooded murder.” Expressing condolences to the Iranian leadership, Putin sharply criticized the American and Israeli military action. In a letter to Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian, he conveyed deep sorrow, stating: “Please accept my heartfelt condolences on the killing of the Supreme Leader of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Sayyid Ali Khamenei, and his family. This act is a cruel violation of all norms of human morality and international law.”

China’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs expressed deep concern over recent developments in the region and called for an immediate ceasefire. The statement emphasized respect for Iran’s national sovereignty, security, and territorial integrity and urged all parties to avoid further escalation, exercise restraint, and return to dialogue and diplomatic solutions. Turkey and Nigeria also offered condolences and stressed the ceasefire and negotiations. If only a similar message had come from Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

Pakistan is often labelled as America’s close ally, yet its Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif expressed condolences on behalf of the government and people of Pakistan. He stated that Pakistan stands with its Iranian brothers and sisters in this hour of grief and expressed concern over violations of international law, noting that heads of state should not be targeted.

Earlier, Pakistan’s Defence Minister Khawaja Asif also described the attack as deeply regrettable. Pakistan supported Iran diplomatically and morally, even condemning the attack at the United Nations. But in India, from the Prime Minister to the Defence, Foreign, and Home Ministers — no one spoke. Hence the question:

Why is everyone silent?

What is the story behind this silence? Please say something.

To repair the damage to India’s global reputation caused by the government’s silence, the opposition stepped forward. Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge strongly condemned the incident, calling it a direct attack on international law and sovereignty. He said that targeting the head of a sovereign state without a formal declaration of war is a grave violation of international law. Therefore, the Indian National Congress clearly condemns this action and expresses condolences to the Iranian people, the late leader’s family, and the Shia community worldwide.

Priyanka Gandhi also wrote on social media platform X that the targeted killing of a sovereign state’s leadership and the deaths of innocent people — regardless of the justification — are condemnable and must be strongly denounced. She said the world needs peace, not more unnecessary wars, recalling Mahatma Gandhi’s words: “An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind.”

Before the violence in Iran, U.S. President Donald Trump had reportedly detained the Venezuelan president and his wife. At that time, Modi had spoken about monitoring the seriousness of the situation. But that issue quickly subsided after the new Venezuelan government surrendered and granted control of its oil resources to the United States.

Iran, however, responded differently. It launched attacks not only on Israel but also on American bases in the Middle East and even targeted a British base in Cyprus. Some missile debris fell in populated areas of Arab countries. Since nearly ten million Indians live in the Middle East, Prime Minister Modi used this as a pretext to speak with Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, President of the United Arab Emirates, strongly condemning recent attacks on the UAE and assuring full support during this difficult time.

The Prime Minister stated that India opposes all forms of terrorism and violence and urged all parties to exercise restraint and responsibility to maintain regional peace. However, he did not explicitly describe the killing of the Iranian Supreme Leader as open aggression. He offered condolences for lives lost in the UAE, even though no such civilian incident reportedly occurred there.

He remarked that such attacks threaten regional stability and global peace and must cease immediately — yet he did not speak about where it all began. Modi once told the Russian President regarding the Ukraine war: “This is not an era of war.” Sadly, he could not say the same to his close associates.

After bringing disgrace from this world to the next, what do people say now, sir? Please say something.

- Advertisement -spot_img

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Must Read

Related News